Freud s theory of psychoanalysis in shutter island

  • Category: Materials
  • Words: 3926
  • Published: 01.24.20
  • Views: 1073
Download This Paper Check the price for your custom essay


Freud’s introduction to the concept of psychoanalysis was one that offered an explanation and a potential solution to an issue that was normally untreated: hysteria. Although Freud’s theory was met with hefty skepticism, it is just a theory that had enough merit to still be used in today’s mental field. Freud acknowledged his theory’s incompleteness but claimed that it was much better than the alternative, to get if an individual provided a total and detailed theory, it would be a product of pure rumours (Freud 5). What makes Freud’s theory of psychoanalysis therefore valuable is that it is successful. Not only as a treatment, but since an explanatory text concerning trauma and hysteria. A first-rate example of Freud’s concepts of psychoanalysis and hysteria may be found in the novel Shutter release Island. Edward cullen “Teddy” Daniels, the leading part of Shutter Island suffers from the symptoms of repression and trauma, great repressed target is looking to surface from his subconscious through the trials in which Daniels undergoes over the novel.

As previously mentioned, Freud’s theory of psychoanalysis was mainly incomplete and was as a result met with objection. His check subjects were very similar inside their upbringing and nature, and it was as well an embarrassingly small evaluation group compared to his colleagues’ work. Not just that, part of his treatment for hysteria and trauma involved the use of a type of hypnosis, a practice scarcely understood even by modern-day psychologists. Freud acknowledged this kind of, and though it was not a complete theory, that still exposed much about trauma and hysteria that a lot of knew very little about. Freud writes once talking about doctors: “He simply cannot understand hysteria. He is in the same placement before this as the layman. ” (2). And what’s more: Freud’s methods, nevertheless somewhat inside their infant level, often times worked well. In fact , the primary idea of his theory can be practiced by simply contemporaries today. At its lowest, the theory supplied a step towards treatment, since, “Hystericals, consequently, tend to drop his [doctors’] sympathy¦” (Freud 2) and often went untreated.

Psychoanalysis operates based on the idea that symptoms of hysteria really are a product of any process generally known as repression. John Wilson publishes articles, “According to Freudian considering the ego is highly selective in what this regards because legitimate elements of itself and censors anything it does not like as a result of disgrace, guilt or perhaps morality. These types of dissociated areas of ourselves will probably be forced apart and retained in the identification. ” This is the fundamental thought of repression: remembrances, thoughts, or perhaps experiences which in turn not agree with our self-image are dispatched into the subconscious (also referred to as id). Freud says, nevertheless , that the repressed object is usually attempting to resurface from the unconscious, he creates, “If a stream flows in two channels, a great overflow of 1 will take place when the current inside the other satisfies with an obstacle. inch (5). This “overflow” is where one could begin to observe hysterical symptoms as a result of repression.

Although there are several case studies, Freud goes into the majority of depth in his lectures relating to a particular circumstance involving damaging symptoms. He describes a lady with “severe paralysisdisturbance of eye-movements, and far impairment of vision, trouble maintaining the positioning of the brain, an intense nausea when the lady attempted to consider nourishment, with one time for several weeks a loss of the strength to drink, in spite of tormenting thirst. Her power of speech was also diminishedshe could neither speak neither understand her mother tongueshe was be subject to states of ‘absence, ‘ of distress, delirium, modification of her whole character. ” (1). It is important to note that until Freud and his partners, these types of severe indications of hysteria frequently went without treatment, for it was obviously a misunderstood and mysterious disorder. Although Freud’s theory was lacking in aspects worth considering, it was able to at least provide treatment for several patients who endured these serious symptoms as well as provide some significant regarding what was otherwise an essentially untouched subject matter. He continue to be write, “The doctorput her in a kind of hypnosis and repeated them to her repeatedly [the objects that have been repressed], to be able to bring up virtually any associationsThe individual yielded to his advice and produced for him those clairvoyant creationsThese were fanciesday dreamswhich commonly got as their kick off point the situation of your girl near the sick-bed of her father. Whenever the lady had related a number of this sort of fancies, the lady was, mainly because it were, liberated and refurbished to her typical mental existence. ” (2). Also, “When this had been going on about six weeks [her not drinking], the girl was chatting one day in hypnosis about her British governess, to whom she disliked, and finally informed, with every sign of outrage, how the lady had enter into the room of the governess, and exactly how that lady’s little doggie, that the lady abhorred, had drunk away of a glassafter she got given enthusiastic expression to her restrained anger, she asked for a drink, drank a large amount of water with no troubleThe indication thereupon vanished permanently. inch (3).

This was the origin of the system known as the “talking cure”. The “talking cure” is essentially the taking out of the overpowered, oppressed object which will would in return lead to the resolution of the patient’s symptoms. The “talking cure” primarily based its strategies off the reality, “The characteristics of the symptoms became very clear through all their relation to the scene which caused them. ” (Freud 3) and that “hysterical sufferers suffer from reminiscences. ” (Freud 4). This is crucial when psychoanalyzing Edward “Teddy” Daniels from Shutter release Island, because the new in its entirety is a item of Daniels’s suffering from repression.

Edward cullen Daniels can be subject to a great immense amount of injury. He was a global War II veteran and was encountered with the most nasty aspects of the already horrific war. One example of his war morsure is as comes after:

“Cawleyplaced a list on the phonograph and the scratch of the needle was followed by stray leaps and hissesReminding him ofa record collection he’d observed in the office of a subcommandant at Dachau, the man listening to it when he’d shot himself in the mouth. Having been still in when Teddyentered the room. Gurgling. (Lehane 76).

Daniels, though a personality with tiny sympathy for injustice, continue to cannot help feeling disturbed by such a gruesome event. Even though this was not his primary injury, it only added to the unfathomable sum of mental distress Daniels was burdened with. Teddy also recounts a more extreme trauma, declaring is as employs:

“They looked at us and in addition they wanted us to do whatever we did. And that we sure because hell desired to do it. And so we carried out every one of all those fucking Krauts. Disarmed all of them, leaned all of them against surfaces, executed themBy the end of these day, we’d removed five hundred souls from your face of the Earth. Murdered them all. Zero self-defense, no warfare arrived to it. It absolutely was homicideThey well deserved so much worsebut how do you live with that? How would you tell the wife as well as the parents plus the kids you have done this thing? You have executed disarmed people? You have killed kids? what you performed was also wrong. And you will never wash it off. ” (Lehane 144-145).

This memory is almost unparalleled in its traumatic scope. Teddy, already coping with the mental distress that is included with war, was posed which has a remarkably tough ethical situation. His very own desires, together with other public challenges, encouraged the execution from the Nazi soldiers, however , the mass-murder of 5 hundred people was a thing that conflicted with his self-image, despite who these individuals were, and thus added even more immense mental stress. To fully understand how strong the injury that actually encouraged Teddy’s misconception was, it is necessary to understand that these traumas were not repressed although merely added stress. The thing that was repressed was something probably much more dark than possibly mass-murder.

The following is the description of any woman called Rachel Solando’s crime, this name however is an alias in which Teddy given to take the area of his wife, Dolores Chanal. Rachel Solando is actually a completely make believe character when the following crime’s blame was placed like a product of delusion and Teddy’s failure to psychologically handle that Dolores Chanel, his wife, was in reality the one to commit the crime:

“Rachel Solandodrowned her three children in the lake behind her house. Took them in existence one by one and held all their heads under until that they died. After that she helped bring them back in the house and arranged them around the dining room table and consumed a meal there” (Lehane 41).

Upon discovering this, Teddy (which he him self should be noted is also a product of misconception, Edward “Teddy” Daniels can be, in fact , Andrew Laeddis)[1] murders his partner. This is the trauma that entirely split Teddy’s consciousness. Wilson writes, “If one will not like an thought or an effect then one merely shuts it out and will not believe it might exist. Concurrently one nurtures and promotes one’s desired belief system and amplifies its lifestyle by repeating and the impetus of obtained duration. “. This is exactly what Teddy (or rather Andrew) suffers from. To totally comprehend what an impact these event got on Snuggly, one need to realize that also in his intricate delusion through which is Shutter release Island, he still recalls the subcommandant as well as the mass-murder. This is mentioned to be fact, as the psychiatrists on Shutter Isle do confirm that Snuggly was a U. S. Marshal and warfare veteran. Referring back to Freud’s case research, we see a lady was still left unable to ingest water as a result of her viewing a dog the lady despised drink from a glass. Evaluate that to Teddy’s shock to the system, and it is obvious that he has extraordinary psychological can. For him to completely bury the stress involving Rachel Solando/Dolores Chanal and body a web of delusion that somehow excluded the situation signifies what serious psychological influence the event had on Snuggly.

Which delusion through which was a product of such a traumatic event is actually frames the plot intended for Lehane’s Shutter Island: Snuggly, a U. S. Marshal looking for escaped murderess Rachel Solando. Snuggly of course does not have any recollection of his true identity or that he murdered his wife and it is also unaware to the fact that Rachel Solando, whom drowned her three youngsters, is in fact a proxy of sorts intended for his better half, Dolores Chanal.

Teddy’s delusion, although remarkably intricate, is not without slight flaws though. Teddy, upon meeting his randomly assigned partner (who is in fact his psychiatrist) observes his partner’s, “olive skin area and slim, delicate hands that looked incongruous with the rest of him, as if he’d borrowed all of them until his real kinds came back from the shop. inches (Lehane 14). His spouse-to-be’s awkward hands was a disparity between what his misconception proposed and reality. This really is seen again when Teddy confronts Rachel Solando (who in reality was obviously a nurse at the institution) and ponders just how, “There was something uncomfortably familiar regarding her¦” (Lehane 43-44). Along with that, there is certainly yet another issue seen when ever Teddy is attempting to resolve a code (in which in turn he undoubtedly created): “Teddy thought it was talking with him, becoming clearerhe may feel something about them scratching at his brainIt was right looking at him. It was so simpleAnd then any kind of possible links of common sense collapsed, and Teddy felt his brain go white¦” (Lehane 52). The reason being for the mental collapse was because he could not consciously fix what his unconscious head had developed without ruining his delusion. His head responds by simply essentially turning down in order to protect his created reality. Along with the previously mentioned, there is another conflict that can be found which takes form in a dream Teddy has. The dream moves as follows:

“He’s here. inch

“Who? inches

“Laeddis. inch

The term crawls through his drag and climbs over his bones.

“No. inches

“Yes. inch She [Dolores Chanal] bends her return, looks up at him. “You’ve regarded. “

“I haven’t. inches

“Yes, you could have. ” (Lehane 89).

All of these occasions are samples of the overpowered, oppressed thought aiming to resurface in to consciousness. Yet , Freud noticed that if the repressed object is contrary enough to one’s morals and integrity, it will always remain buried in the unconscious for an untold period of time. Such is definitely the case in all of the aforementioned instances.

Dreams enjoy a significant role in the psychoanalysis of Teddy, as the”Interpretation of dreams is in factthe interpretation from the unconscious¦” (Freud 11). Teddy’s dreams may corroborate with Freud’s state, as they usually provide some sort of regards to Teddy’s stress with his wife. In one wish, he views his partner, and “the back of her is charred, smoldering a bitand tiny ribbons of smoke loosen up from her hair. inches (Lehane 87). Then, “she’s no longer burnt, she’s soaking wet. inches (Lehane 87). The reason he sees his wife charred and burnt is because your woman had used up their outdated apartment down. Teddy repressed that celebration too, for this was mentally too hard for him to procedure and, following your burning of their apartment, made the decision it would be better for their friends and family to move to a cabin, which is presented over the following segment of his wish: “the look at of another place they stayed once, a vacation cabin. There’s a small pond to choose from with little logs floating in it¦” (Lehane 88). Then, “Her belly suspension springs a flow and the the liquid flows through his hands, ” (Lehane 88) and, “His tears spill straight down her physique and mix with her serving belly. inch (Lehane 89). The constant continuing theme of water is perhaps one of the most useful in its relation to his past trauma, recognizing the symbolism in water is crucial because it represents the drowning of his children. To help confirm this, his children are what he refers to as the “small logs” floating inside the water. The value allotted to water runs past mere dreams, Teddy also suffers throughout the story from severe sea-sickness. Along with that, Teddy was regularly being reminded of his dead better half by relatively random issues, and one of many triggers with the most significant impact in this was water: once referring to items that told him of his partner, Teddy observes “nothing was less reasonable in terms of connective tissue, or more pungent in terms of effect, than water¦” (Lehane 20). This, of course , had not been random although instead was directly related to Teddy’s previous trauma through which his kids were drowned by his wife, which explains why water experienced such a devastating impact on him.

Another sort of a dream that allows the reader to peek in to Teddy’s subconscious is one out of which Teddy and Andrew Laeddis both equally switch roles in having sex with Rachel Solando and Dolores Chanal with seeming randomness. This kind of ease of interchangeability is due to the simple fact that Teddy and Toby are one in the same, as are Rachel and Dolores, how they are separate is by means of Teddy’s misconception. Sleep can be described as time with no consciousness, as a result there is fewer resistance against the repressed object to area.

Snuggly, already under extreme internal stress, also suffers physiological symptoms. When ever referring to warfare veterans, Jeneen Interlandi writes, “In conjunction with their disturbing dreams and hallucinations, many of them a new host of physical illnesses including severe headaches, fatigue, intestinal troubles and shut down. inch. In her paper “How do you Recover a Traumatized Mind? inches, Interlandi electrical relays her experiences with psychiatrist Bessel truck der Kolk. One of these experience was a role-play similar to the 1 Teddy experienced. The role-play subject was a man named Eugene, “his job included disposing of erupted bombs. It had been a year of dead bodies, he explained. He noticed, touched, smell and moved in more physiques than he could possibly count number. Some of them were children. ” (Interlandi). This is not entirely in contrast to some of Teddy’s war trauma. Also, “Eugene killed a great innocent person and then observed as the man’s mother discovered your body a short while after. ” (Interlandi). While Eugene and Teddy suffer independent traumas, they both are war-related and they both equally yielded physical issues. These issues surfaced because, “repressed thoughts were a common feature of traumatic pressure. Traumatic encounters were not being processed in to memoriesbut had been somehow obtaining ‘stuck in the machine’ then expressed throughout the body. ” (Interlandi).

Perhaps Teddy’s most widespread physiological indicator is headaches. These severe headaches often work out as planned when Snuggly faces any conflict among his delusion and reality. Some examples with the pain this individual suffers from severe headaches are: “A dull aches settled in the left side of his brain, just behind the eye, like the smooth side of an old spoon were constrained there. inch (Lehane 21), “Teddy was feeling the area in the back of his skull by that point. inches (Lehane 113), “a encolure filled with lava cut throughout the skull just beneath the part in his hairthe soreness erupted like a dozen dagger points moved slowly in to his cranium¦” (Lehane 175), etc . It could be noted the fact that latter of most of these, which can be perhaps one of the most extreme physiological aches and pains he endures, was after confronting Rachel Solando.

Even Freud talked about internal disturbances leading to physiological symptoms: “they experience a change in unusual physical innervations and inhibitions, which will present themselves because the physical symptoms of the case. ” (5). Kamuf produces of one other symptom: “a foreign body is always an indicator, it always does indication [fait symptome] on the body in the ego, this can be a body overseas to the physique of the spirit. ” Snuggly, in several circumstances throughout the book, expresses the discomfort he feels in his own body system. Interlandi as well confirms this kind of symptom in saying, “Trauma victimsare alone from their body by a cascade of incidents that starts deep in the brain. inches. These physiological occurrences just add to Teddy’s incomprehensible amount of stress.

Sabouri and Sadeghzadegan write, “what indeed gives rise to the psychotic state of Andrew is the excessive duplication and repeat of his delusions, hallucinations and dreams whose singular message is a reminiscence ofpast traumas this individual finds him self unable to recollect. “. Teddy (in reality, Andrew Laeddis) is a victim of clampdown, dominance, his partner drowned their particular three kids and he in turn killers her. This really is a in a big way dark function, and Teddy responds to it simply by entirely shutting it out by his awareness and then formulating an elaborate and thorough web of delusions through which allow him to continue living those memories. His delusion offers that call him by his name is Edward cullen “Teddy” Daniels, a U. S. Marshal searching for escaped murderess Rachel Solando upon Shutter Isle (the place in which he could be institutionalized for having murdered his wife and having been a victim to extreme internal pressures). The psychiatrists in Shutter Isle allow Teddy to play out his misconception in the hopes it may act as sort of parallel to Freud’s “talking cure”. In fact , Freedman publishes articles about an author who handled her repression via producing: “Writing pertaining to H. D. takes on the magical as well as the therapeutic worth of the speaking cure intended for Freud. inch. The psychiatrists are trying to locate a successful approach to extract Teddy’s trauma in order that he may face the reality and ultimately always be relieved of his various psychological and physiological symptoms. Unfortunately, the trauma demonstrates too extreme and Snuggly is ultimately unable to access the overpowered, oppressed object by his unconscious and improvement to a point out of actuality, and the audience is left with a case analyze that highlights the puzzle and incompleteness in which we all understand psychoanalysis and even psychology as a whole. Despite his regular living in delusion, it is said by Teddy’s psychiatrist that, “In his very own peculiar way, he hated lies more than anyone I possess ever noted. ” (Lehane 2).

Performs Cited

Freedman, Ariela. Gifts, goods and Gods: H. D., Freud and trauma. The english language Studies canada, vol. 29, no . 3-4, 2003, p. 184+. Books Resource Centre, login. ezp. mesacc. edu/login? url=http://go. galegroup. com/ps/i. perform? p=LitRCsw=wu=mcc_mesav=2. 1id=GALE%7CA169457976it=rasid=3eddccf0edc325dbf9e136ca709dcba8. Accessed 3 Nov. 2016.

Freud, Sigmund. Wonderful Books in the Western World. Chi town: Encyclopaedia Britannica, 1988. Print out.

Interlandi, Jeneen. How would you Heal a Traumatized Brain? The New You are able to Times Publication, 25 Might 2014, p. 42(L). Books Resource Center, login. ezp. mesacc. edu/login? url=http://go. galegroup. com/ps/i. perform? p=LitRCsw=wu=mcc_mesav=2. 1id=GALE%7CA369148198it=rasid=06875ca262827670c7ce3c33bb58d0b7. Accessed several Nov. 2016.

Kamuf, Peggy. The deconstitution of psychoanalysis. Variety: A diary for the interdisciplinary analyze of materials, vol. forty two, no . four, 2009, s. 35+. Materials Resource Centre, login. ezp. mesacc. edu/login? url=http://go. galegroup. com/ps/i. carry out? p=LitRCsw=wu=mcc_mesav=2. 1id=GALE%7CA214547706it=rasid=f2a5ceda50719ffb3e1d4dcbd69bf27f. Accessed 3 Nov. 2016.

Lehane, Dennis. Shutter Island. Nyc, Harper, 2009.

Sabouri, Hossein, and Majid Meters. Sadeghzadegan. Distress and mental distortions in Dennis Lehanes Shutter Tropical isle. Theory and Practice in Language Research, vol. a few, no . a couple of, 2013, s. 376+. Materials Resource Middle, login. ezp. mesacc. edu/login? url=http://go. galegroup. com/ps/i. perform? p=LitRCsw=wu=mcc_mesav=2. 1id=GALE%7CA351081922it=rasid=5a16e662f1dc9c3a121e56ba627a4243. Accessed several Nov. 2016.

Wilson, John G. Repression: psychoanalytic and Sartrean phenomenological perspectives. Existential Research, vol. 21, no . 2, 2010, g. 271+. Books Resource Center, login. ezp. mesacc. edu/login? url=http://go. galegroup. com/ps/i. do? p=LitRCsw=wu=mcc_mesav=2. 1id=GALE%7CA288874200it=rasid=01fe1738437108731fd7a909b1f733f4. Accessed a few Nov. 2016.

[1] The reason being for my discussing Andrew Laeddis as Edward cullen “Teddy” Daniels is because the narrative comes after the latter name throughout the book, In Teddy’s delusion, Claire Laeddis can be assigned the crime of getting killed Teddy’s wife, because the thought of him killing his own partner was too much to emotionally bear, and Andrew Laeddis (who, actually, is the protagonist) instead turns into a completely distinct entity through the fictitious personality of “Edward ‘Teddy’ Daniels”.

Need writing help?

We can write an essay on your own custom topics!

Check the Price