Compare and contrast judith ortiz cofer s catch

Download This Paper

Compare Essay

Love is an feeling that deeply alters someone’s thought-process. This kind of emotion can bring out the best of people or even make them question who they are and what they’re willing to quit for the person they appreciate. In Judith Ortiz Cofer’s short history “Catch the Moon”, your woman suggests that take pleasure in can change a person for the better by making these people want to enhance themselves. However , in Watts. D. Wetherell’s short account “The Bass sounds, The Riv, and Lin Mant”, he suggests that take pleasure in can make a person try to always be someone they may be not, finally leading in disappointment and regret.

Though both authors center all their stories within the topic of affection, they fluctuate greatly from their character disputes, character improvements, conflict resolutions, and their designs.

In “Catching the Moon”, Luis Cintron and his daddy constantly dispute and never go along very well. However , when Luis meets her named Naomi, he activities an feelings that reconnects him along with his dad.

Meeting Naomi causes Luis to experience love—an emotion this individual hasn’t experienced since the fatality of his mother—and causes him to actually want to develop better character because he knows that his mother will need him to be happy. In order to demonstrate his superior character to both Naomi and his dad, Luis searches all night for the hubcap that may match the one which Naomi is looking to get. After hours of searching, Luis finally finds the link cap and rushes to get it to Naomi. Cofer states that Luis, “…waited to give her [Naomi] the first positive thing he had provided any one in a long time” (Cofer, pg. 240). This kind of quote displays that because of his new love, Luis was willing to change his personality for the better and that take pleasure in can genuinely reconnect aged flames from the inside oneself.

“The Bass, The River, and Sheila Mant” portrays a different message than that of “Catching the Moon”. In this short story, the narrator faces an internal issue between deciding on over his two passions—Sheila Mant and fishing. The narrator has always wished for impressing Andrea Mant, yet he wavers when Sheila criticizes fishing for being stupid and monotonous. Regardless of her opinion, the narrator continues his quest of flattering Sheila by using her on the boat trip and gonna a popular party. On the way to the party, a fish gets caught on the fishing range the narrator left out on the boat, through the have difficulties the fish puts up, he knows that it’s the striper he’s recently been waiting most summer to catch. Thoughts rush through his mind, and even though the narrator features waited every summer just for this fish, this individual chooses Lin instead. The narrator reduces the line, goes toward the party with Sheila, and provides his center broken once she decides to forget him another guy.

Out of this experience, the narrator learns that there are a lot of fish inside the sea and shouldn’t include changed him self just to get a female to like him. This individual even procedes say that, “There would be other Sheila Mants in my life, different fish, even though I came close once or twice, it was those secret, invisible tugging in the night that claimed myself, and I by no means made a similar mistake again” (Wetherell, pg. 150). This quote demonstrates the story’s theme of not really changing who you happen to be for take pleasure in because it only will result in feel dissapointed and disappointment.

Love is an extremely complex feeling. There are a lot of rules to like, as well as a lots of exceptions to rules. All in all, in order to have a cheerful relationship, a single must do wish makes your self happy. In the event that someone’s happiness is place in jeopardy just because of a romance, then the marriage was not really meant to be. Put simply, when entering a marriage, don’t select the better boy or girl; choose the boy or girl that will make you a better person.

Works Mentioned

Cofer, Judith Ortiz. “Catch the Moon. ” 2003. Holt Literature and Language Artistry. 4th education. Austin, Tx: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 2003. 234-40. Print. T. D. Wetherell. “The Bass sounds, The Riv, and Andrea Mant. ” 2003. Holt Literature and Language Artistry. 4th impotence. Austin, The state of texas: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 2003. 245-50. Print.


Need writing help?

We can write an essay on your own custom topics!