The Chrysanthemums vs the Story of an Hour Essay

Download This Paper Check the price for your custom essay

Elisa Allen in Steinbeck’s “The Chrysanthemums” and Louise Mallard in Chopin’s “The History of an Hour” have quite a lot in common due to the fact that they equally went through comparable struggles. The two Elisa and Louise end up being strong girls that clearly had desires for their own such as being corresponding to men and having a passionate relationship using a man. Even though that may be true, they was missing resemblance inside the true desire they each yearned for.

First of all, Elisa and Mrs. Mallard related from the point of view that they the two faced the sad fact that women inside their time periods were unbearably unequal to guys. For example , in “The Chrysanthemums, ” it absolutely was clear that ladies had zero say in the commercial aspects of activities such as running a ranch. This is obvious when Steinbeck writes that “Elisa seemed down across the yard and saw Henry talking to two men in operation suits… Elisa watched these people for a moment and then returned to her work” (229).

It’s obvious that Elisa’s view on the business aspects of the ranch are completely disregarded. If her opinions do matter then she would be around her spouse and the organization men producing decisions together. In addition , girls could not be free to delete word travel along the countryside. This kind of becomes obvious when Elisa tells the Tinker coming from “The Chrysanthemums” that living a travelers life has to be nice and the tinker responds by stating “It ain’t the right kind of a your life for woman” (234). The way the Tinker responded clearly demonstrates that the idea that society has about women in their time period much more of a stay at home mom kind of thought.

They don’t see females as travellers or outdoorsmen. Lastly, women could not live for themselves just like Mrs. Mallard wished in Chopin’s “The Story of your Hour. ” This is especially obvious shortly after finding out her husband had passed away. Mrs. Mallard starts whispering to himself “Free, free of charge, free! ” (169).

Clearly women in her time frame were not allowed to do anything they will wanted. They’d to stay in the home, raise kids, and be housewives, otherwise Mrs. Mallard wouldn’t have seemed so excited to be free of charge. Secondly, equally Elisa and Mrs. Mallard were awfully lonely and unhappy with their marriages.

Initially this comes across is the moment in “The Chrysanthemums” Steinbeck writes “Her hesitant hands almost handled the cloth… She crouched low such as a frowning dog… she was standing up incredibly straight, her face was ashamed” (234). Undoubtedly, Elisa yearned to get a passionate marriage so much so that she was practically tossing herself on the Tinker. The girl felt ashamed because she realized that her intentions had been wrong and she was flirting having a man that was not her husband. Although it doesn’t clearly express whether Mrs. Mallard was lonely or unhappy with her marital life Chopin shows that she was.

The fact that Mrs. Mallard was sharing with herself “Free! Body and soul free of charge! ” (Chopin 170) following finding out regarding the death of her husband advises she was unsatisfied with not just her life although her romance as well. If perhaps Louise had had a keen and partnership with her husband probably she wouldn’t have been so intensely cheerful that her husband got passed away. In addition, she wouldn’t have been so captivated with the idea of getting free.

Though Elisa and Mrs. Mallard both related in their problems, they differed quite a bit in the ultimate desire they each got. Mrs. Mallard wanted a lot more than anything to become free which comes across obviously throughout Chopin’s “The Tale of an Hour. ” About more than one event Mrs. Mallard shows how ecstatic she is to finally be free of charge.

Mrs. Mallard not only shows she would like to be free of charge by frequently whispering to herself “Free, free, free of charge, ” (Chopin 169) but it shows in her loss of life as well. The moment Mrs. Mallard saw that her spouse was in she perished because her dream of finally being able to do what your woman pleased was gone.

Her only wish was extracted from her speedy. On the other hand, though Elisa wished things could be different for ladies (that they could be free perform to as they please) that showed that what your woman wanted much more than anything was going to have a passionate relationship with someone. This is particularly evident when ever Elisa has a encounter with all the Tinker then when at the end from the story “The Chrysanthemums” Steinbeck writes that Elisa “turned up her coat collar so he [her husband] could not see that she was crying weakly…” (237). Following the encounter that Elisa got with the Enhance she experienced as if there was clearly still an opportunity that your woman could have some sort of romance in her your life.

Later, your woman sees the chrysanthemums that she experienced given the Tinker placed on the side in the road. Just then truly does she realize that she have been taken good thing about by the Upgrade simply to gain business, not really because he was actually interested in her. At this point their almost like Elisa collapses on the idea of having some kind passion in her existence and your woman just stops working crying. Without a doubt, Elisa and Louise were both regrettably devastatingly depressed women with ambitions of their own.

Elisa in Steinbeck’s “The Chrysanthemums” and Louise Mallard in Chopin’s “The History of an Hour” related inside the struggles they will faced psychologically and the problems they experienced in culture but in the end they differed in the the case desire they each had.

Need writing help?

We can write an essay on your own custom topics!

Check the Price