Mental illness and kid abuse article

Mental Disorder, Twice Jeopardy, Kid Abuse, Maltreatment

Excerpt from Essay:

Mental Health issues and Child Abuse

The physical abuse of children was ‘rediscovered’ simply by physicians over fifty years ago. Since that time, some experts have indicated concern on the continuing ‘medicalisation’ of the actual consider being essentially a social problem (Parton, 1985). A widely-held view emerged from the resulting debate that child physical abuse and neglect took place through an conversation between parents, children and the social environment. The version described parents with psychological conflicts, taking care of vulnerable kids, while moving into circumstances of social stress (Schmitt and Krugman, 2005). In the circumstance of this version, parents who have maltreated youngsters were not generally considered to be suffering from a psychiatric disorder.

Nevertheless , recent study into kid abuse and neglect have not fully backed this presumption. In particular, evaluations of child deaths have shown significant associations with parental mental health problems. Exploration in this area continues to be hampered simply by problems of definition. The idea of ‘child abuse’ is better considered as a social building in which guidelines for appropriate parental habit change with time and differ from culture to culture (Reder et al., 2003). This has allowed some studies to work with the existence of just one bruise because their index of ‘abuse’, and some have focused on whether legal courts had removed a child by parental attention. In addition , research workers do not usually distinguish between the several forms of kid abuse and neglect. Issues also arise with psychiatric diagnoses, and arguments continue as to whether substance misuse or personality disorder, for example , constitutes a psychiatric disorder. In our perspective, the former does, because it may lead to disturbances of consciousness, believed and feelings, while the latter does not, because it primarily details long-standing issues with relationships that originated in negative childhood activities (Reder and Duncan, 1999). Our preference is to use a lot more general term ‘mental health problems’.


Many bloggers are at pains to point out that a lot of psychiatric sufferers can is to do parent effectively (Oates, 2007). non-e the less, in comparison with controls, father and mother who maltreat their children are usually shown to be frustrated (Falkov, 1997) or to have a history of attempted committing suicide. Sheppard (1997) used the Beck Major depression Inventory to measure mothers in whose families made-up child and family cultural work caseloads: he discovered a significant affiliation between maternal depression and recorded kid maltreatment, especially physical and sexual abuse. Glaser and Prior (1997) reviewed the cases of children whose names had been on the Kid Protection Subscribes of four British local authorities. Parent mental illness, including suicidal attempts, anorexia nervosa, depressive psychosis and schizophrenia, was present in 31 per cent of cases and substance misuse in 26 per cent. These types of compare with frequency estimates inside the general human population for despression symptoms of 15 per cent (Kandal et ‘s., 2004) and for schizophrenia of just under you per cent, and the calculation that 7 per cent of parents beverage harmful degrees of alcohol (Cleaver et al., 1999).

In an extensive project, Oliver (2005) reviewed the histories of families moving into an area of southern Great britain which contained successive generations of child maltreatment. He figured, ‘In the parents and antecedents, mental and personality disorders, suicidal endeavors, mental problème, dependence on medicines (mothers) or perhaps on alcohol (fathers), epilepsy and criminality were noticeable features’ (p. 484).

In the United States, Taylor ainsi que al. (1991) and Murphy et ing. (1991) examined the data of 206 serious physical abuse and neglect instances brought prior to Boston Teen Court. They will found clear evidence of a severe affective disorder in a single or both these styles the parents in 14 % of situations and a psychotic disorder in 13 per cent.

Parental mental medical problems also feature on the number of research-based risk check-lists. For example , Browne and acquaintances evolved protocols for forecasting which mom and dad are most likely to abuse and/or neglect youngsters (Agathonos-Georgopoulou and Browne, 1997). The family member importance of risk characteristics was determined by discriminant function research, and a brief history of parental ‘mental health issues, drug or perhaps alcohol addiction’ was located to be a significant predictor of later kid maltreatment.

Kids vulnerability

A prospective research by Rutter and Quinton (2009) on the effects of parent psychiatric disorder on little one’s psychological welfare and creation provides a beneficial link to our understanding of the increased risk of child misuse and overlook by this sort of parents. They found the impact was not disorder-specific but was more dependant on the sociable and relational consequences with the parents’ disorders. In other words, the youngsters were generally affected by their very own parents’ basic functioning and behavior.

We believe that this means well to problems of child abuse and neglect, through which it is the outward exhibition of the parents’ problems through their patterns that greatest describes the chance to their kids. For example , parents who are self-preoccupied and emotionally and practically unavailable (as a result of depression, psychosis or element misuse) are more inclined to neglect youngsters, as are individuals who show capricious or chaotic forward organizing due to psychosis, depression or substance improper use. The recurrent separations which can be the consequence of repeated hospital vestibule may also lead to emotional or physical neglect. Physical abuse is more likely to derive from parental becoming easily irritated or over-reaction to stress that sometimes accompanies anxiety, depression or psychosis, as well as the parent’s distorted philosophy or aggression during psychotic episodes. Uncommon parental preoccupations as part of obsessive conditions or perhaps phobias can also lead to physical abuse in the children. Is it doesn’t disinhibition and boundary-blurring of substance improper use that can boost the risk of child sexual mistreatment.

Mental health conditions

We discovered a substantial affiliation with parental mental health conditions. Among the thirty five ‘confirmed’ circumstances, in which the caretaker responsible for the child’s death had been recognized, 15 (43 per cent) of the perpetrators had been affected by an active mental health problem at that time that they slain the child. Three were exhibiting evidence of a paranoid psychosis and this was a probable prognosis with a last. Two had a depressive disorder and an additional two postnatal depression. To get the remaining seven, the problem was significant substance misuse. Furthermore, two of the four father and mother with a paranoid psychosis likewise significantly mistreated drugs and/or alcohol. Two other perpetrators had a earlier psychiatric record.

Considering every 49 cases, which include the ‘suspicious’ along with ‘confirmed’ deaths, requires all of us to look for an energetic mental health problem in either of the current caretakers, seeing that no criminal was referred to as responsible for getting rid of the child inside the ‘suspicious’ situations. In the 35 ‘confirmed’ instances, 2 associates of the perpetrators had shown evidence of a present mental medical condition, which was element misuse in both occasions. In the 14 ‘suspicious’ instances, 4 caretakers in 3 families experienced had an active mental medical condition, one being depression with somatic issues and the staying three being substance improper use.

Assessment paralysis

A particularly stunning process concern arose from your study. The presence of parental mental health problems seemed to have a serious impact on the functioning of members from the child safeguard networks included in the people, which we have termed ‘assessment paralysis’. All of us mean by this an evident impasse in the professional network which interupted with thinking about the needs in the child together with those of the parent. This occurred if the parent revealed delusional thinking with irrational behavior, or perhaps evidence of a depressive condition. Professional matter became focused on whether the father or mother did, or did not, have a diagnosable psychiatric disorder. While this concern was clearly relevant, because it decided whether that parent necessary admission to a psychiatric clinic, if necessary under a Section of the Mental Health Act, it became the component which made a decision whether any kind of intervention was possible. Once the general practitioner or psychiatrist considered that the parent or guardian was not displaying evidence of an official psychiatric disorder, members with the child safeguard network looked unable to insist that the parent’s behavior was so strange or so dangerous that, regardless of what label was put to this, the child required protection from it.


To conclude, then, parental mental health issues do appear to increase the likelihood of child maltreatment in general, with substance misuse particularly associated with non-fatal and fatal child abuse. It appears to be the lifestyle that accompanies illicit drug work with that affects so adversely on child care (Swadi, 2005). However , effective treatment could be a significant defensive factor.

Obviously, clinicians must be sensitive for the welfare of children of psychiatric patients. This is certainly well illustrated by the three patients mentioned by Mogielnicki et approach. (1977), who presented into a casualty division with psychosomatic complaints including chest pain, arm or leg weakness, head aches and visible blurring. Psychiatric interviews says they dreaded being chaotic to their children or were already imposing harm to them. Instead of showing disguised warnings of risk to their children, parents may possibly occasionally communicate obsession preoccupations with doing harm to their child. Press button and Reivich (2010) describe successful psychotherapeutic treatment of such mothers, non-e of whom acted upon their particular murderous thoughts.

Need writing help?

We can write an essay on your own custom topics!

Check the Price