Analysis of the movies soloist vs the devil s

The Soloist

Both videos, The Soloist and The Devil’s Violinist happen to be about genuine musicians even though living in different centuries. Whilst both videos focus on the emotional lives of these two musicians, they will approach the niche from different perspectives. The Soloist is known as a realistic portrayal of events surrounding Nathaniel Ayers, as the Devil’s Geigenspieler uses the cliched tale of selling your heart to the devil to achieve fame and dominance.

Nathanial Ayers was a talented music performer (bass, cello and violin) who had a good career prior to him. When studying at Julliard he collapsed under the tension and had a psychological malfunction and finished homeless on the streets of Los Angeles. Finally his state was clinically diagnosed and this individual responded to medicine and surely could have a reasonably normal your life after many years of hardship. He achieved balance due to the support and knowledge of friends, particularly journalist Charlie Lopez who took up his cause and ultimately told his story. Underneath care, Ayer’s was eventually able to live a life as a functioning musician and member of society.

Paganini was a great Italian geigenspieler and composer in the early 1800’s. This individual wrote music that was revolutionary intended for the time and would take those world years to cope up to his harmonic and melodic difficulties. While not pictured in the video, Paganini suffered from many emotional disorders and contracted syphilis, which ultimately led to his death. Offered the time of his your life, one cannot accurately identify his mental disorders, but clearly the movie attempts to portray his many obsessions, abuses and addictions. The film could not realistically talk about and or diagnose his condition as we could today. In cases like this, the director/writer chose to concentrate on ideas of times that great (satanic) pushes were in place to explain his abnormal mental behaviors.

It’s not really a stretch to draw the conclusion that with great expertise frequently come mental medical issues. Statistically musicians have a very excessive rate of depression. Performers think in a different vocabulary, one that is much more connected to feelings than to logical or perhaps rational thought. Perhaps because of this, musicians have a tendency for psychological disorders. Superb musicians will be consumed by their work and the drive may be harmful and lead to internal issues. Fortunately, people fully grasp this now and much greater acknowledgement and help obtainable than in Paganini’s day as well as during Ayer’s college years, which were not that long ago. Acquired Paganini existed today, probably he would have received medical care so that he also could have existed a longer, more comfortable and more prolific life.