Wonderland vs neverland essay

Everyone looks at growing up in another way. Some want to hold onto their very own childhood purity, whilst other folks have lost that, struggling to find a far more mature id. The fictional works of Alice’s Journeys in Wonderland by Lewis Carroll and Peter Skillet by L. M. Barrie each deal with one side of the transition between childhood and adult life. For Alice, the world of adults is perplexing, but the lady wants to fit in, wants to become older, and is also tired of getting treated just like a kid.

The girl strives being older simply by acting the part of a mature fresh woman, her world of Wonderland reflecting this fact, as its older, is made up of more mature themes and concepts, and ultimately assists little Alice through her child to adult transition, allowing her to find herself.

Peter is fairly the opposite. For him, growing up can be described as definite not any, and he holds on to his purity at any cost. His world, Neverland, portrays this kind of, as everything is strictly good or wicked, black or white, with an obliviousness to see the great line among, and allows Peter to determine who he can.

These types of young protagonists are between a ensemble of personas that support outline which in turn side the separate creators take on developing up, and just how such things as purity, maturity, personality and escapism all enjoy parts in these coming of age tales.

Alice is seven-years-old. While most kids her age are playing “with a number of toys from feel dolls to toy military and train sets and enjoying all their youth, Alice is examining, learning language from her sister, and thinking about the day’s weather (Lambert). Quite a bit more grown up compared to the other children in the nineteenth century, Alice believes their self to be a grown-up, acting much beyond her age, and facing problems with a much more mature frame of mind. Although mixed up and a little frazzled when falling down the rabbit hole into Wonderland, she immediately sets herself goals and explores, pressing herself on with an air of experience. Once faced with the bottle that says “DRINK ME, your woman shows himself knowledgeable, permitting readers know she’s noticed all about different types of poison, and knows that “if you drink much coming from a bottle marked ‘poison’ it is almost certain to disagree along, sooner or perhaps later (Carroll 8).

The promotion of her apparently vast knowledge-beyond-her-years and maturity continues through the novel, since Alice highlights several occasions to several of the Wonderland personas such as the Caterpillar and later, the Mad Hatter and the Queen, that she is not just a kid, and that’s she actually is much more matured than they presume. Numerous instances in the book show that Alice interprets herself to get older and more mature than she is, and show readers what exactly side Carroll seems to be dealing with the issues of growing up. With the Caterpillar, it seems never to faze her at all that he’s sitting on a mushroom smoking, which isn’t something which typically occurs in a children’s novel, neither should she be exposed to. Secondly, one should remember that the mushrooms and comprimé Alice must eat or drink to grow larger to smaller sized are similar to drugs of the real world, because they alter an individual’s perception, much like the way they affect Alice’s perception in the already whacky Wonderland. Additionally , her regular growing and shrinking showcases a child or perhaps adolescent going through changes through puberty and inability to modify before going by using a bit of self-discovery.

The only problem is that no matter just how grown up Alice thinks she is, and can action, saying she knows just about everything, her ending up in the Duchess, who feedback that Alice “[doesn’t] understand much, and that is a fact causes her to realise she in fact understands nothing, and still has a a lot to learn via both Wonderland and her own globe in order to grow up (Carroll 45). The greater mature establishing of Carroll’s Alice’s Escapades in Wonderland shows readers he plainly identified with children developing up, producing the move from faithful child to mature mature as quickly and independently as is feasible. In contrast to this, a book suitable for kids, Carroll’s subjects, designs and emblems are far more mature than M. M. Barrie’s Peter Baking pan.

Some kids simply usually grow up when it is period. They may want that responsibility, they will don’t wish to change, and so they don’t want to become an adult. They wish to remain “gay and innocent and heartless, and that is exactly what Philip plans to complete by staying in Neverland forevermore (Barrie 111). He tells Wendy immediately that he ran abroad because he overheard his parents “talking as to what [he] was to be when [he] started to be a man and decided that this individual wanted to “always be a little youngster and to have got fun (Barrie 17). Philip is afraid of losing this kind of by growing up, and clings to anything that enables him to be a child, the key example of this being that this individual needs a mother, which this individual finds in Wendy. Although he tells her this individual wishes on her behalf to see the mermaids in Neverland, it is evident by his declaration towards the Lost Young boys that inches[he hast] helped bring at last a mother for [them] all that his plan every along was to get them a mother.

One could think that Peter would play the father to her mother, since he’s responsible for the Lost Boys, yet such does not apply. Again Peter’s childhood chasteness shines through, because he will not play the role of daddy: she’s intended to be his mother too. He doesn’t need that responsibility, he does not want to be someone else, and he really wants to go on adventures and battle pirates for all those his existence. At the end in the novel, Wendy brings the Lost Males home, but Peter will not go along.

This individual knows that acknowledging means growing up, and that is something he will not carry out. He promises that he could bring Wendy back to Neverland, but when he returns, this lady has grown older, and he’s unwilling to acknowledge this kind of. So , he takes her daughter Anne to Neverland to be his mother is to do his planting season cleaning instead, and later takes her daughter Margaret, “and thus it will eventually go on, provided that children are gay and lesbian and harmless and heartless (Barrie 115). In this way, we see that Peter never genuinely grows up, keeping his child years values and innocence forevermore, and, contrary to Alice, by no means wonders who also he is, or what his place in the adult globe will be.

Loss of identity is actually a frequent and sometimes unavoidable incident that occurs with becoming an adult and leaving the world of a child. Alice knows just who she is just before her excitement in Wonderland, as well as after. But she experiences an alteration wandering through Wonderland that mirrors the self-discovery a young child goes through when creating the transition from kid to adult. The misunderstandings she experience is mainly caused by the developing and downsizing and changes her human body undergoes in Wonderland, comparable to puberty. Once she stumbles across the Caterpillar following a number of growing and shrinking, this individual queries her:

“‘Who are YOU? ‘ stated the Caterpillar. This was not a great encouraging beginning for a discussion. Alice replied, rather shyly, ‘I-I rarely know, sir, just as present”at least I understand who I WAS when I received up this morning, but I believe I must have been completely changed a couple of times since then’ (Carroll 37).

This takes place several even more times throughout Wonderland, with Alice becoming constantly ordered to identify their self the animals she fulfills and unable to properly answer. In addition to the Caterpillar’s berating, Alice has a operate in with the Cheshire Cat, where he tells her that quite simply inches[they’re] all upset here. [He’s] mad, [she’s] mad and knows she is, “or [she] wouldn’t attended here (Carroll 48). This kind of causes her to query herself and her individual sanity, and wonder exactly what she is undertaking here in Wonderland, and who also exactly she is.

Everyone has informed her she is international, called her something aside from Alice and accused her of something or additional at some point inside the novel, and it’s almost too much for the young woman to bear. However , she comes out on top of it all towards the end, fighting again against the California king of Hearts and becoming her own 3rd party woman. The alterations she undergoes in order to come back home at the conclusion of the novel are a parallel to puberty and the work of finding her own personality, showing that Carroll features demonstrated the transition between childhood and adulthood which despite bumps along the street (finding herself), Alice has grown up properly. This is actually the opposite of Peter, yet , who continues to be unchanging for the length of his story.

“All children, other than one, increase up (Barrie 1). It really is evident from your first line of the story that Peter won’t become an adult any time soon. He knows who he could be: a kid. A child who battles pirates, shields the Misplaced Boys and spends his days in happy bliss, doing what he would like when he wants, no guidelines or limitations in Neverland. Not having to grow up means he gets to stay that way, and doesn’t need to undergo the self-discovery that comes with maturing and obtaining older. This individual displays this kind of several times through the novel, the most known being when Wendy provides to have him play the role of daddy to the Shed Boys and her brothers, as she actually is the mom. He denies, preferring to keep in the part of the “son, because that’s what this individual knows, which is the part he’s constantly played, predetermined.

He’s uncomfortable even posing as someone nevertheless himself, entirely comfortable with his identity. Barrie conveys anxiety about growing up through Peter’s eyes, explaining that simply by maturing and becoming a man in the event that he extends back home together with the Darlings, after that he’ll have to become another individual, and lose the id of whom he is at this point. It was the entire reason this individual ran apart in the first place. As opposed to Alice, whom undergoes a big change in the book and makes the transition at the conclusion, he is still the same as ever before by the time Philip Pan finishes.

When he drops in by using a elderly Wendy’s window, she notes that “he [is] exactly the same as ever before,  and she “sees at once that he continue to [has] all his first teeth (Barrie 112). She actually is grown up, Jordan and Steve have grown up, even the Lost Boys the lady brought back are now adults, although Peter, some, is a kid. In this way, Barrie allows him to keep every factor of his personality that he may have lost, turning into someone besides Peter Griddle, by growing up, displaying again that staying fresh seems to be even more favourable that growing up. Despite the fact that he didn’t grow up and Alice did, they discuss once prevalent trait that ties with each other their views on growing up: escapism.

Fantasy is explained by the book as a “habitual diversion from the mind to purely innovative activity or perhaps entertainment while an escape by reality or routine (Merriam 426). This is exactly how equally Peter and Alice deal with their developing up, or perhaps lack thereof. This escapism is supposed to ease these people through the youngster to adult transition, or perhaps, in Peter’s case, to continue to keep it from occurring. In order to help achieve all their goals, these worlds had to be adapted in order to reflect their particular author’s look at of developing up which has been and will be underlined throughout the book.

For Alice, there is Wonderland. A dream universe created to break free the monotony of the adult world the lady faces that help her associated with transition from child to adult much easier. The brand itself explains to readers what’s going on ” a Wonder. This symbolizes Alice’s ever continuous curiosity and wonder about everything as your woman learns she must control herself if she is to the adult world, as well as how wonderful the world is. Carroll allows him self to echo his suggestions that children should older fast and grow up by creating mature styles and perhaps innuendos within the web pages of Wonderland, the easiest example of this becoming the Caterpillar. Upon wandering through the forest, Alice’s “eyes immediately [meet] those of a large caterpillar, that [is] sitting on the top of a mushroom with it’s hands folded, silently smoking an extended hookah rather than taking the tiniest notice of her or perhaps anything else (Carroll 36).

Hookahs will be banned in many places as they are considered unlawful as they are employed for recreational prescription drugs. In the real life, such a thing would never come anywhere around someone since young as Alice, nor would it become appropriate. To place such an adult theme within a children’s book shows that Carroll was most for growing up quickly. In addition to this, the cakes and drinks which make her bigger or small are also any reference to prescription drugs, as mentioned before. They adjust her perception of the world about her, very much like they do in real life, demonstrating once again that the world Alice offers escaped to reflect the truth that she’s growing up and becoming a mature adult. Though Neverland is a world in the same way magical while this one, their symbolism lies at the opposing end with the spectrum.

Neverland is and always has been Peter Pan’s residence. A magical world filled up with mermaids, fairy godmothers, pirates and Indians, in which the “good guys are children and the “bad guys will be adults. This kind of simple fact, that children are very good and adults are poor, reflects Peter’s very mindset that developing up is a horrible factor, and Barrie’s ability to transmit this simple fact to his readers. In many ways, Neverland signifies the “good in the author’s eyes, since it is filled with carefree children, who are able to do what they wish and never have any problems, whereas the “read world would stand for the “bad as it is a great adult’s world where actuality must be confronted and problems like cash, food, physical violence and fatality come into play. It truly presents a infant’s mentality, as a world away from our own to flee to if the going gets tough.

Additionally , the identity of Peter’s world shows the position they have taken upon growing up, as you “Never grow in Neverland. Barrie takes things a step additional to summarize the fact that Peter’s world must signify his concepts of under no circumstances growing up so firmly that by one point in the story, Peter starts to take “intentionally quick short breaths with the rate of approximately five into a second since “there can be described as saying in Neverland that, every time you inhale and exhale, a parent dies; and Peter was killing all of them off vindictively as fast as possible (Barrie 74), showing us Peter’s globe really reflects the author’s vision of children staying children forever. Barrie has created a world vastly unlike that of Carroll’s Wonderland, and this is because both equally authors have demonstrated their look at of developing up simply by creating two children’s stories with totally different perspectives.

In the end, some people make the transition, changing and establishing in order to become a much more mature person, whilst other folks simply don’t, remaining similar to they have been. For Alice, her voyage through Wonderland has aided her in developing a new identity, in blending her childhood innocence and adult life maturity collectively, as well as defeating her escapism in order to become a grown up young lady. Even at the beginning, when the Caterpillar asks in the event she believes she’s transformed, she responds that she has “afraid [she] is. [She] can’t keep in mind things because [she] used-and [she doesn’t] keep the same size for ten moments together!  (Carroll 38).

However , this lady has accepted that she is changing and growing up, which can be more than can be said for small Peter. This individual refuses to alter for Wendy all through the entire novel, and the end, he’s “exactly the same as ever which includes having “all his 1st teeth, without having made the transition, keeping a firm grasp on his chasteness, his identity and getting away to Neverland in order to avoid his problems (Barrie 112). Two sides to a single coin, Alice and Peter’s stories wonderfully reflect Carroll and Barrie’s stances within the issues of whether to grow up or perhaps not.


Need writing help?

We can write an essay on your own custom topics!

Check the Price